How A Trump Victory Could Be A Boost For ETFs

A Donald Trump presidency could introduce several potential advantages for exchange-traded funds (ETFs) due to shifts in regulatory policies, market dynamics, and investor interest. A range of specific factors, from regulatory ease to stock market trends, could foster a favorable environment for ETFs. Let’s dig a little deeper. 

1. Ease of Regulatory Rules by the SEC

One of the primary areas where a Trump administration might impact the ETF landscape is through regulatory adjustments by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Trump has previously shown support for scaling back financial regulations, particularly with a view toward bolstering market growth and reducing barriers for investors and companies. This could have several direct implications for ETFs:

• Simplified Compliance: A Trump-led SEC may prioritize reducing compliance burdens for financial institutions, including those managing ETFs. This could mean streamlined reporting requirements or fewer disclosure obligations, which could lower administrative costs for ETF issuers and make it easier to launch new funds.

• Increased Approval Speed for ETFs: SEC leadership under Trump might also prioritize a more efficient approval process for new ETFs. This could expedite the release of innovative products, particularly in areas like cryptocurrencies or thematic ETFs that might appeal to a broader base of investors but currently face regulatory hurdles.

• Support for Digital Asset ETFs: Given Trump’s recent acknowledgment of the growing importance of digital assets and blockchain technologies, a more accommodating stance toward cryptocurrency ETFs could emerge. This could lead to faster approvals for Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other crypto-backed ETFs, which many investors are eagerly awaiting.

2. Stock Market Performance and ETF Growth

Historically, stock markets have often responded positively to Republican administrations, especially in sectors such as energy, defense, and finance, which may benefit from deregulation and pro-business policies. A Trump administration could stimulate the market in ways that specifically enhance ETF performance:

• Sector-Specific Growth: ETFs tied to sectors that typically thrive under Republican policies, such as financials and energy, could see increased investor demand. For example, during Trump’s previous administration, deregulation in the energy sector boosted oil and gas stocks, benefiting energy ETFs. A similar approach could yield positive results, with potential growth for sector-specific ETFs tied to traditional industries.

• Broader Economic Growth: Trump’s policies often focus on reducing corporate taxes and encouraging domestic investment. If enacted, such policies could boost overall economic growth, which may reflect positively on the stock market. Broad-based ETFs, such as those tracking the S&P 500 or the Dow Jones Industrial Average, could benefit from a strong U.S. economy. 

On the day after the election, we saw the largest boost in small-cap related stocks as the Russell 2000 was up over 5%. This is a sign that small companies might be more optimistic in a Trump presidency. 

3. Innovation and Investor Interest

A regulatory environment that favors reduced oversight and increased financial flexibility could create more opportunities for innovative ETFs. Additionally, certain changes under a Trump administration may resonate with investor interests, increasing demand for ETFs in specific areas:

• Emergence of New Themes: Investors may see the creation of thematic ETFs that align with current political or economic trends. For instance, funds focused on sectors like infrastructure, defense, and cybersecurity — areas of interest during Trump’s previous administration — could attract significant attention and capitalize on government investment.

• Crypto and Blockchain ETFs: Trump’s recent commentary suggests he recognizes the significance of the crypto and blockchain sectors. If his administration aligns with these views, the SEC may adopt a more open stance toward crypto ETFs, which could attract a substantial investor base looking to gain exposure to digital assets. The presence of approved Bitcoin or Ethereum ETFs could add a layer of legitimacy to the crypto market, bringing in both institutional and retail investors.

• Greenlight for Leveraged and Inverse ETFs: While these products come with higher risks, they offer potentially high rewards for investors. Trump’s SEC might be less inclined to restrict the creation and promotion of such ETFs, leading to a wider variety of options for sophisticated investors willing to take on additional risk.

4. Derivative and Options Based ETFs

A Trump administration could be beneficial for derivative-based ETFs in a few ways, especially if it results in policies that encourage market volatility, economic growth, or favorable tax treatments for financial products. Here’s a breakdown of how it might impact derivative ETFs specifically:

• Increased Market Volatility: Policy unpredictability, often seen during Trump’s first term, could create market fluctuations. Derivative ETFs—especially those with options or futures—thrive in volatile markets as they use derivatives to hedge, speculate, or enhance returns. Higher volatility often leads to higher trading volumes and investor interest in derivative ETFs as they offer tools to manage risk or capture gains.

• Tax Policies: If the administration introduces policies that lower taxes on capital gains or certain financial transactions, this could lead to increased interest in ETFs in general, including those using derivatives. Derivative-based ETFs sometimes attract investors with short-term, tax-efficient strategies, and favorable tax policies would likely make them even more appealing.

• Number of ETFs Using Derivatives: Over the past decade, the number of ETFs that incorporate derivatives has grown significantly. As of the latest data, hundreds of ETFs employ derivatives in some form—such as options overlays, futures, or swaps. These ETFs range from sector-based funds to leveraged and inverse products that use derivatives to amplify returns or hedge against losses. Derivative ETFs vary in popularity, with leveraged and inverse ETFs, which frequently use futures, being particularly popular among short-term traders. Options overlays, which are often used to enhance income in high-dividend ETFs, have also grown in popularity.

• Dividend ETFs with Options Overlay Strategies: Dividend ETFs with options overlays, like covered call strategies, are increasingly popular among income-focused investors. These funds generate additional income by selling call options on their holdings, which can be appealing in uncertain or low-growth environments. Under the Trump administration, if interest rates remain low, demand for these types of ETFs might stay robust. Many income-focused investors look to these ETFs as they offer higher yields than traditional dividend ETFs through option premiums. The use of options overlays also offers some downside protection, which could attract investors wary of volatility or looking for alternative income sources.

5. International Distribution and Global ETFs

Changes in international relations and trade policies could also impact the ETF market, particularly for globally focused funds:

• Potential for Higher Returns in Emerging Markets: Trump’s trade policies tend to emphasize protectionism and bilateral agreements over multilateral deals. This shift could create unique opportunities for ETFs focused on countries that benefit from U.S. trade policies. For instance, ETFs targeting Mexico, Canada, or Asian economies might see unique price movements based on specific trade relationships.

• Increased Appeal of U.S.-Based ETFs: If Trump’s policies encourage “America First” economic priorities, foreign investors may view U.S. focused ETFs as a safer or more lucrative option than international funds, given the potential growth of domestic industries. This could make U.S. equity ETFs more attractive to both domestic and international investors, potentially increasing fund inflows.

6. The ETF Rule and Share Class Approval

The SEC’s ETF Rule (Rule 6c-11), implemented in 2019, was a significant step in making it easier for issuers to launch ETFs without the need for individualized exemptive relief. A Trump-led SEC might look to enhance this rule further, potentially in the following ways:

• Lower Barriers for New Entrants: An expanded ETF Rule could mean that even smaller fund managers would have fewer regulatory obstacles to contend with when launching new ETFs. This could result in a more competitive and diverse ETF market, providing investors with a broader selection of funds.

• Faster Approvals for New Share Classes: If the SEC under Trump is more willing to experiment with ETF structures, this could accelerate the approval process for different ETF share classes. This flexibility could be particularly beneficial for financial advisors and retirement plan providers who seek customized fund options for their clients.

7. Adoption by Defined Contribution Plans

One of the most impactful policy changes could involve encouraging the inclusion of ETFs within defined contribution (DC) plans, like 401(k)s. While mutual funds have traditionally dominated these plans, there is growing interest in expanding ETF options due to their typically lower fees and tax efficiency:

• Potential Legislation Favoring ETFs in Retirement Plans: Trump’s administration may propose or support policies that allow for greater use of ETFs in 401(k) plans, particularly those that aim to reduce fees and improve retirement outcomes for workers. If so, the regulatory environment could shift to make ETFs a more common option in DC plans, thereby increasing ETF adoption rates.

• Enhanced Retirement Portfolio Options: With more flexibility in retirement plans, employees might gain access to ETFs that offer greater diversification, such as sector or international ETFs, which are less commonly available in current DC plans. This could be a significant draw for investors who are interested in building more sophisticated, diversified retirement portfolios.

8. Sales, Marketing, and Investor Education

With a favorable regulatory backdrop, ETF issuers may invest more in educating investors and promoting the benefits of ETFs over other investment products. If ETFs gain further regulatory support, issuers might amplify marketing efforts to capture a larger share of the retirement and retail investment markets:

• Expanded Education on ETF Advantages: Trump’s SEC might encourage or be open to financial literacy initiatives that highlight the benefits of ETFs, such as cost efficiency and liquidity. This educational push could attract more individual investors who are currently unaware of how ETFs could fit into their portfolios.

• Potential for Broader Marketing in Retirement Accounts: ETF providers might find it easier to market their products as alternatives to mutual funds in retirement accounts if the regulatory stance becomes more favorable. With an expanded presence in retirement funds, ETFs could see increased adoption across a broader investor base.

The Next $10 Trillion in ETFs

Regardless of your political views, the potential changes in the regulatory, economic, and investment landscape could yield several specific advantages for ETFs. From streamlining SEC rules to promoting innovation, a Trump administration could encourage a more dynamic and diverse ETF market. This environment could see heightened investor interest, especially in sectors aligned with Trump’s policies, such as energy, defense, and infrastructure.

The combination of eased regulatory barriers, expanded ETF options in retirement plans, and favorable market conditions could pave the way for significant growth in the ETF industry, benefiting investors and issuers alike.

The post How A Trump Victory Could Be A Boost For ETFs appeared first on Tom Lydon.